Monday, May 18, 2009

Hanhu chavurata #6

We've gotten word of many more stories in the independent minyan world since last fortnight's column!

  • This week's top story is Los Angeles's newest prayer community, the Westside Minyan. Founded by people who moved west from New York, it is modeled after Kol Zimrah: full liturgy, guitar accompaniment, mostly singing, two-table potluck, etc. The Westside Minyan is actually the second minyan in LA that can claim lineal descent from Kol Zimrah: Minyan Malei Shirah was inspired by Kol Zimrah Jerusalem z"l (which was founded by people from the original Kol Zimrah in New York, but had a different style from the beginning, hence the two styles now coexisting in LA). As far as I know, there is no connection to the West Side Minyan on the Upper West Side of Manhattan (the minyan founded in the '70s that later became a part of Congregation Ansche Chesed and spun off Minyan M'at).
  • In my hometown of Chicago, this past Friday night was the first meeting of the brand-new apartment minyan in Lakeview, a neighborhood with a hopping Jewish scene. It's so new that it doesn't have a name yet, but one of the founders wants to call it Mitzpeh Yam (i.e. Lakeview, or perhaps Seaview, but it's a Great Lake).
  • We also hear that there are new minyanim in Charlottesville, Virginia (home of the University of Virginia) and Princeton Junction, New Jersey (home of the Dinky). That's all we know so far.
  • Minyan Tehillah in Cambridge, Massachusetts, is a "10+10" minyan: they define a quorum as 10 men and 10 women. (This requires twice as many people as either an egal minyan or a conventional non-egal minyan.) For large minyanim that have this policy, such as Shira Hadasha in Jerusalem, a quorum is always present anyway. Smaller "10+10" minyanim can be put to the test when they have to decide what it means for them if they don't have 10 of each: Do they continue as if there is a minyan? Do they continue as if there is no minyan? Do they wait indefinitely? We have previously linked to an account of one minyan's struggle with this issue (the Mission Minyan in San Francisco). Because Tehillah has not always had 20 people of the appropriate genders, they called a town hall meeting for last night to determine what to do in this case. No word yet on the results.
  • What we reported last time about the bike ride home from the Hadar Shavuot Retreat was too good to be true; the bike ride was cancelled due to insufficient registration. The same cannot be said for the retreat itself; as usual, it has sold out and there is a waiting list. For some reason, people don't seem to want to bike 50 miles so soon after staying up all night.

10 comments:

  1. About the 10+10 - what does a member of such a minyan do when asked to be counted in a minyan which does not respect 10+10? Decline? cooperate?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Also, BZ, this is good for your polemics: more and more minyanim are starting in decidedly suburban areas!

    ReplyDelete
  3. email me at gmail as bfleischer for info on the new Chicago minyan/potluck whose name may or may not be mitzpeh yam.

    Our first meeting this past shabbat was great.

    BZ left out the formerly Partnership now egal Lakeview Minyan in Chicago

    ReplyDelete
  4. Benjamin writes:
    BZ left out the formerly Partnership now egal Lakeview Minyan in ChicagoCool! So what are the differences between the Lakeview Minyan and the new unnamed minyan?

    ReplyDelete
  5. About the 10+10 - what does a member of such a minyan do when asked to be counted in a minyan which does not respect 10+10? Decline? cooperate?The people who attend 10+10 minyanim are heterogeneous in their personal approaches to the issue, so I suspect there's not one answer that applies to everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Obviously, but I was trolling for different answers.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow, apparently I'm quite late to the party--thanks so much for the link to your "two-table potluck system" post. That's so new to me that I just linked to it. Too bad I didn't know about the two-table system when I was writing about kashrut dilemmas a couple of years or so ago.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Chicago's Lakeview Minyan has been up and running for about a year. I've been going and its nice. They also seem to have occasional potlucks. They even have some communal approach to decision making which is cool- they sent around a survey about how we should approach halachic issues. I appreciated that.

    I don't know why Benjamin feels he has to replicate it just two blocks away when he could just join them.

    Options are good, but maybe its another case of 2 Jews 3 opinions...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Chicago's Lakeview Minyan has been up and running for about a year. [...] I don't know why Benjamin feels he has to replicate it just two blocks away when he could just join them.

    Does the Lakeview Minyan meet every week? Does the new minyan meet the same weeks as the Lakeview Minyan? If the answer to both of these questions is no, then the new minyan is still filling a needed role.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The new Princeton area minyan is called Zamru. See Zamru.org for more info. We're also developing an innovative children's educational program called Yerusha. Zamru is piloting the program. See Yerusha.org for more info. Zamru and Yerusha are starting up fall '09.

    ReplyDelete