Now that I'm in the old country with fewer distractions (except turkey), there's time to blog the Talmud.
Megillah 10b-11a:
Where we
last left off, the Gemara on this
perek had called it a day on commenting (in the broader sense) on the Mishnah, and had begun an extended midrashic work on
Megillat Esther. We're still in the introduction.
Rabbi Levi has yet another received tradition from our ancestors: the
ark that contained the tablets took up no space. Just do the math: the inner sanctum was
twenty cubits in each dimension, and each cherub took up
ten cubits, leaving zero cubits left over. Thus the ark only stood because a miracle suspended geometry (just like how there was room for everyone to prostrate themselves even though they were standing shoulder to shoulder). Far be it from me to second-guess a received tradition, but why do we assume that the ark and the cherubim were collinear? Why wouldn't they be arranged like
this picture or
this one or any other graphic representation of the ark?
The next step, before we dive into the text of Esther itself, is a series of
petichtas to introduce the book. This is a homiletical form (seen in places like Vayikra Rabbah and Pesikta d'Rav Kahana) that
ends with the target verse (often from the Torah), and begins with a verse from far away in Tanakh (often an unrelated verse from Neviim or Ketuvim), and gets from B to A by a complex chain of associations. But in this case, all we see is the verse from elsewhere and maybe a line or two of explanation. Each rabbi has his own
petichta for Esther, each with the goal of situating Esther conceptually within the rest of the biblical tradition. Each one has a different idea about the main take-home message of Esther.
1) R. Yonatan opens with
Isaiah 14:22. For him, the beginning of Esther is the fulfillment of the prophecy against Babylonia. Achashverosh's empire of 127 states is already evidence that Babylonia is no longer the dominant power. Isaiah's prophecy says that God will cut off Babylon's
sheim (this refers to writing: no Babylonian writings survive except through other nations. Can the historians here address the veracity of this claim?),
she'ar (this refers to language: the Aramaic language is dead, except in that one village in Syria, and ironically, among the Jews),
nin (this refers to the kingship), and
neched (this refers to Vashti, who according to tradition was the granddaughter of Nebuchadnezzar). Thus, the removal of Vashti is, for R. Yonatan, the completion of Bavel's fall.
I should note here that I was a bit surprised here (and further on) to see Vashti portrayed as a villain. In all the communities I've run in, Vashti has always been seen as a sympathetic character and/or feminist heroine (who stood up to Achashverosh's drunken misogyny), and it didn't occur to me that the rabbis would have thought otherwise. We then made a list of other characters who seem ok from the plain sense of the text, but whom the rabbis turned into bad guys. This list included Eisav, Bil'am, and Ishmael.
2) Rabbi Shmuel bar Nachmani opens with
Isaiah 55:13. As do we. Could he have known that one day, this would be read as the
haftarah on the afternoon before Purim? The
na'atzutz is replaced with
berosh: Haman, who made himself an idol to bow down to (and
na'atzutz is
associated with idolatry), is replaced with Mordechai, who is
rosh of all the spices ("[
besamim rosh]
mor deror" is translated into Aramaic as "
marei dechai"). The
sirpad is replaced with
hadas: Vashti (granddaughter of the one who burned the
roof of God's house -
saraf refidat beit h') is replaced by Esther (Hadassah). The last clauses of the verse (about an eternal sign) refer to the reading of the
megillah and the days of Purim.
3) R. Yehoshua ben Levi opens with the curses in
Deuteronomy 28:63. So for him, Haman's attempted destruction of the Jews was a gleeful divine punishment for their sins.
But then we see an objection to the idea that God is happy about the downfall of the wicked. When Moab and Ammon get defeated, Israel exclaims
"hodu ladonai ki le'olam chasdo". "
Ki tov" is missing, because God
isn't happy.
This is the source for the famous midrash that when the Israelites crossed the sea, the angels began singing, until God said "My creations are drowning, and you sing songs of praise?!". Thus, we spill out wine from our cups for the Ten Plagues, and we abridge
hallel during Pesach. Even the people we don't like are God's creations.
Rabbi Elazar resolves the contradiction: God itself doesn't rejoice, but makes others rejoice (
yasis is in the causative). Whether or not this is the ideal response, it is certainly empirically true that humans rejoice at their enemies' downfall.
4) Rabbi Abba bar Kahana opens with
Kohelet 2:26. Mordechai is the good guy, Haman is the bad guy, and Mordechai and Esther end up with Haman's stuff at the end. This is the cowboy reading of Esther: the good guys always win.
5) Rabbah bar Ofran opens with
Jeremiah 49:38. Elam is Persia. Again, a prophecy about upheaval is fulfilled. The
melech is Vashti (in a gender-bending role), and the
sarim are Haman and his ten sons.
6) Rav Dimi bar Yitzchak opens with
Ezra 9:9. Self-explanatory: God has "extended mercy to us in the sight of the kinds of Persia".
7) Rabbi Chanina bar Papa opens with
Psalm 66:12. We went through fire (in the time of Nebuchadnezzar) and water (in the time of Pharaoh), but now it's all going to be ok.
8) Rabbi Yochanan opens with
Psalm 98:3. Self-explanatory salvation.
9) Reish Lakish opens with
Proverbs 28:15. The lion is
Nebuchadnezzar. The
bear is Achashverosh (since those Persians eat and drink like bears, get fat like bears, grow hair like bears, and are restless like bears - funny, I thought bears were known for sleeping). The wicked ruler is He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, and guess who the humble nation is.
10) Rabbi Elazar opens with
Kohelet 10:18. Israel got lazy with the
mitzvot, so (if such a thing were possible) God got weak, leaving Haman with free reign to attack Israel's compromised immune system.
11) Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak opens with
Psalm 124:1-2. God saved us when a plain old
adam, not a king, rose against us. That's right, it was Haman!
12) Rava opens with
Proverbs 29:2. Guess who the "righteous" and "wicked" are supposed to be. This verse encapsulates the plot of the
megillah, but in reverse order, thanks to comic inversion.
13) Rav Matanah opens with
Deuteronomy 4:7 - look how great we are!
14) Rav Ashi opens with
Deuteronomy 4:34, and he gets the last word, so Purim is framed as a story of Pesach-like wonders and redemption.
In conclusion, Esther is a Rorschach test.
***
Exegesis begins.
VAYHI BIMEI ACHASHVEROSH!!! IT HAPPENED IN THE DAYS OF ACHASHVEROSH!
Vay vehi -- oy vey!
Rav sees the glass as
half empty, while Shmuel sees it as
half full. Yes, this is a story of exile and persecution, but even in the worst of times, God hasn't forgotten Israel. Even in the time of Nebuchadnezzar, there was Daniel and his buddies. In the time of the Greeks, there were Shimon haTzaddik and the Maccabees. In the time of Haman, there were Mordechai and Esther. In the time of the Persians (here the rabbis talk about their own time), there were the rabbis! And in the future, no nation will be able to rule over Israel.
Shabbat is about to arrive in Chicago, so I'll stop there for now.
